Thomas Aquinas - Jurisprudence Notes

Leave a Comment
·         Aquinas came around the time when the power of the church was declining and concept of secular state was gaining momentum.
·         Aquinas intended to counter this secularism wave through a rational argument.
·         He argued that political state is based on the natural needs of man.
·         The order, as God is responsible for both needs and their satisfaction. state is part of a divine
·         The controlling principles of the universe supplied the ultimate criteria by which human laws must be judged.
·         Aquinas then divided law into further four categories:-
o   Eternal
o   Natural
o   Divine
o   Human

Eternal law

·         Aquinas believed that universe is the creation of God.
·         He argued that since God is rational by nature, the universe cannot be random.
·         Eternal law is divided into two more categories:-
o   Laws that are subject of physical, biological and social sciences and according to which universe functions
o   laws of behaviour that distinguishes right and wrong conduct
·         Eternal law is not knowable as to know eternal law is to know God’s mind and that is not humanly possible.
·         Aquinas illustrated this using example of sun by arguing that we do not know what sun is like but merely an idea from its effects on earth.
·         Since every person is subject to eternal law why there exist wrongdoers. Aquinas gives two reasons:-
o   human beings have imperfect knowledge of the eternal law and therefore are prone to error
o   the eternal law rewards good people with happiness and punishes the bad ones

Natural Law

·         Laws forming part of the eternal law that are followed despite not knowing them.
·         Human beings follow laws of nature such as eat, drink and sleep despite not knowing about the biological functions of human body,
·         Natural law is that part of the moral eternal law that rational human beings understand by their God given reason, which is denied to physical objects and other animals.

Divine law                                

·         It consists of the Ten Commandments and other authoritative Scriptures.
·         It is important because:-
o   Natural law only helps in survival to aspire to a higher supernatural end directions are needed which are given in divine laws.
o   Human understanding to interpret natural rule is flawed and may lead to wrong interpretation. Hence, cardinal moral rules need to be prescribed.
o   Human made laws cannot govern direct interior acts.
o   Human laws cannot punish evil all evil without hurting common good. Eg – Cannot ban virtues like lust, selfishness, impatience etc.

Human law

·         It consists of law established by custom or by the legislative acts of the state.
·         Aquinas held that the moral authority for human law making is found in that part of the eternal law which reason reveals to man in the form of natural law.
·         There are two ways in which human law is derived from the natural law:-
o   By deriving logical consequences from the self-evident premises of natural law
o   By determining the way natural law applies to particular types of cases
·         There exists three pre-conditions for the recognition of an enactment as a law at all:-
o   Law is made for the common good
o   Law is made by the whole people or by God’s vice regent for the whole people, who is the monarch ruling by divine right

o   Law is promulgated

0 comments :

Post a Comment